Grotto PizzaGrotto Gift Shop Address 70 Rehoboth AvenueRehoboth Beach, DE 19971Located in First Street Station (302) 727-5393 Hours of Operation Call (302) 227-3567 for our seasonal hours shop online Visit Our New Gift Shop Located at First Street Station. Get your Grotto Pizza gifts, collectibles, apparel, and more! enjoy Grotto Pizza. earn points. get rewards. join today